The Olympics: Why They're Tape-Delayed
I keep seeing anger expressed in the direction of NBC for tape-delaying the Olympics on the west coast, and it seems like it's all over. "Why is this tape-delayed? I'm on the west coast! Vancouver is on the west coast! That's the same coast! Why is NBC so stupid?"
I hear you, Magellan, it's annoying to know the score of the game before the game is over, and you want to watch it live in case there's any wardrobe malfunctions. Unfortunately, it's not as easy as all that.
First of all, a quick note: I'm not picking on anyone in particular, it just seems like this has been mentioned often enough that maybe I can inform a soul or two so they won't be as angry. Here's the thing, the Olympics are not the most popular programming in the world. Most people can't name all the events, I'll go out on a limb to say 9 out of 10 Americans can't name all fifteen winter Olympic events comprised from seven different sports, and if you're an American, that also means 9 out of 10 of you are employed and doing "business" during "business" hours, which means you're most likely home to watch T.V. at prime time. Some of those 9/10 people's business is to sell us things, and they're not going to pay NBC as much to carry the Olympics to show us commercials for those things they're selling if they don't know there's going to be eyeballs there to drink it all in.
Whoops, I said the magic words. Yes, NBC is getting paid to show the Olympics. No, they are not profiting from it, at least they're not planning on it. It turns out they're planning on losing $250 million when showing these games. They're betting against themselves, which is kind of sad.
Secondly, as a west coaster, I couldn't care less about other (read: lesser) time zones, but more than three quarters of the U.S. audience is in Central and Eastern time, and they get all kinds of cranky if you keep them up past their bedtimes. Plus, this way, we get to share the experience, and nobody has to feel left out at the water cooler the next day. I mean, unless you're some total loser who doesn't watch prime time television, am I right?
Thirdly, NBC thinks we like it better this way, and they might be right. Their own research shows they get better ratings when they do this as opposed to making us try to catch events at inconvenient hours, when nobody is home. They plan on showing some events live, but filling in the other time with pre-produced biographies. The theory is you might care more about the athletes and their sports if you get to know them. It works often enough for me. Show me J.R. Celski's blood gushing from his leg onto the ice by the pint just last September, I'll watch him skate now that he's recovered. Seems fair, right?
"I accidentally my skate and leg!"
Fourthly, while the instant-update world is very vocal, they're either in the minority, or just complaining while they're watching. Saturday's airing of Apolo Anton Ohno's silver medal race was watched by 26.2 million people, which is more than any of the nights four years ago in Torino. The two-night average (that includes the opening ceremony) of 30 million is the highest for a winter games outside the U.S. since Lillehammer in 1994.
Fifthly, if you're that passionate about these sports and have to watch them live, NBC is offering live streams with over 400 hours for footage on their various Internet presences and Universal Sports. If that's not enough and you have the time to be watching obscure winter sports in the middle of the day (and I don't even do that), you can probably find the time to head up to Canada to watch all the events live on CTV.
So there you have it, not only does NBC lose less money than the maximum amount they possibly can, but you like it better this way; you just didn't know it.
As an aside, I knew that Apolo Ohno had taken the silver hours before it aired. I watched the event anyway, and my brain almost did a back flip inside my skull when the three Koreans were ahead of him. "He won silver!" my brain exclaimed to me... itself... as we sat in awe, watching the events of what could be a parallel universe unfold. Instead, the Koreans crashed out, universes collapsed back into each other, and my brain sent orders to my mouth to utter the words, "holy shit."
Sources:
Vancouver Olympics Coverage Requires Fewer Tape Delays, Except for West Coast Viewers - WSJ.com
Olympics score for NBC - Variety
[Note by Axion, 02/15/10 1:29 PM PST ] The live streaming schedule is here.
2 recs |
16 comments
|
Comments
Good stuff (as always), Ax.
www.FriarsOnCardboard.blogspot.com
"jbox does not drink coffee, as it makes him clean house big time." ~Kev
Nice job defending The Man
However, I still hate the delay.
Sure, re-air the events when they’re on, but nobody can convince me that running an infomercial on your primary networks is somehow making more money than just running the live feed of whatever you’re taping at that point.
Run the Speed Skating event (or whatever premier event it is) live for the west coast at 7:30PM or whenever it happens to show and then tape delay it and fill your 10:00PM on the West Coast. People are used to Bob Costas telling them, “And now, we’ll air the blah blah event from earlier tonight.” You get to sell the same programming TWICE.
It’s not like NBC has all of this programming that’s so amazing right now. They actively booted a GOOD piece of programming (Conan O’Brien), because they couldn’t figure out a better way of working the schedule so as not to completely burn that bridge. Their response? Go back with “proven” programming (read, the tired stuff that worked 5 years ago, but won’t keep you in the race in 2012).
Really, is it the viewer’s fault that NBC has never understood the value of sports? This is the company that let their NFL agreement go away only to watch Fox completely blow them out of the water. NBC’s response? Overpay for the NFL and then whine that you can’t turn a profit on it.
I keep reading about how the Olympics are a loss leader for NBC like it’s a bad thing. The whole point of having a loss leader is that you can expect to turn a profit on the rest of your products. When Fox airs a sporting event, I know the Fox lineup for the entire year by heart. On NBC, I know about Parenthood and The Marriage Ref. Two shows that appear to target the same demographic, and I know nothing else about anything else. Maybe they should actually TRY to make money before complaining that they can’t make money.
THE OLYMPICS SHOULD BE LIVE. I’m no fan of Comcast, but thank goodness they’re buying NBC. At least they have SOME idea of what to do with television programming.
by Dex on Feb 15, 2010 10:51 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
The Conan thing is different
I can’t speak to the appeal or ratings of Martha Stewart or Judge Who’s-it vs. a live feed nobody’s watching, but that’s affiliate buying from syndicator territory. NBC itself doesn’t put that on, NBC San Diego is in charge of what we see at those times, which is why NBCOlympics.com is handling live streams as to not rock the boat more than they already have with the Conan thing.
The Conan thing was about affiliates getting screwed by Leno being on before their evening news, which made everyone change the channel. Local affiliates’ money mainly comes from their news programming, so they were pretty pissed Leno was coming on beforehand and stinking up the joint. And that tired stuff that worked 5 years ago is probably going to come back in the form of Conan’s show being on Fox this fall. And hell, maybe if Conan got GOOD enough ratings before Leno ruined it for the affiliates, NBC would have seen the value in keeping him. Obviously they saw through with the Johnny Come Lately numbers the controversy drummed up.
I don’t know any details of the NFL deals, and that only seems related to tape-delay or the Olympics because it was NBC.
The viewers are voting with their eyeballs, and they’ve voted that they like tape-delay, again. The Olympics also easily beat everyone’s Sunday night last night.
I don’t feel sorry for them that this is a loss leader, I was trying to express the duality in watching the Olympics, seeing all these athletes who have the sky as their limit, and NBC walking in knowing this is a losing endeavor, but I didn’t color it up so well. Frankly, everything looks like a loss for them to me, besides their Thursday nights.
It’s really no different than why Cox doesn’t air Padres games on Ch4 during the day, which also makes sense to me.
And does this mean you’ll be watching the Lady Canucks take on the Swiss Misses? Puck drops at 2:30pm!
Isn't it enough to know that I ruined a pony making a gift for you? ◔ヮ◔
Uncommon Sportsman :: Absurdity in play
But there's no other vote...
Who’s to say that the Olympics wouldn’t do even better if they aired live on the west coast and then re-aired in prime time?
The Conan thing just points out that there’s obviously room for programming on the NBC channels.
The NFL thing is just pointing out that NBC thought there was no money to be made in broadcasting NFL games either. NBC doesn’t think there’s money to be made in broadcasting MLB or NBA or NASCAR.
In this day and age, when there are so many time shift options for watching television, the ONLY thing that’s even halfway decent live is sports. It would be one thing if NBC was touching up what we saw on delay to make it better when we do see it (a la WSOP), but they don’t even do that.
The affiliates voted this way
It’s cheaper for them to show syndication than it would be for the network to take over, especially when the network’s commercials aren’t making the affiliates any money. So it’s the affiliates who probably didn’t want to give up their territory.
Isn't it enough to know that I ruined a pony making a gift for you? ◔ヮ◔
Uncommon Sportsman :: Absurdity in play
I, for one, am glad
That Jeopardy keeps airing at 7:30 despite the Olympics ransacking NBC’s scheduling for two weeks.
I'm the first person to admit that I'm wrong about a lot of things, but I'm going to be the last person to admit I'm wrong about what we're currently talking about.
Bolts from the Blue - General Manager: It is what it isn't
Still doesn't make it right!
There’s still no GOOD reason why it shouldn’t be live on the west coast.
If affiliates lose too much revenue
they’d have to make cutbacks and perhaps even fire personnel; affiliate personnel in the form of our favorite local personalities, such as Chrissy Russo.
Therefore, I posit that the GOOD reason it can’t be live is because of Chrissy Russo, or NBC7’s equivalent, whoever that is.
In our case, none of this matters, because I just looked up and found out that NBC San Diego is owned and operated by NBC.
So I blame a combination of stay-at-home moms and the East Coast.
Isn't it enough to know that I ruined a pony making a gift for you? ◔ヮ◔
Uncommon Sportsman :: Absurdity in play
Tape Delay
I was ready to rant about the tape delay, just like Dex, but I think that I’m subconsciously one of the people that “likes it this way.” First off, part of it has to do with this being the winter games and there being less stuff to follow. During the summer games there is a massive amount of sport that I want to envelope myself with as much current stuff is possible. I know I can’t watch everything s I’m using the internets to find out what’s going on and I already know stuff before it airs in primetime (especially with the time differences in places like Sydney, Athens and Beijing). With the Winter Olympics, with the exception of Hockey and Curling, they are putting almost everything I want to in primetime, so I know I can do other stuff for a while, maybe catch some of the qualifying or prelims early in the day (if its a weekend and I have time) and then see a mix of live and tape delayed stuff at a specified time slot. And with the delay being at most a handful of hours and me not checking the current results online, I don’t really know what happened yet like I did in Beijing. Even then though, I still tape delay it myself by using my DVR to skip over commercials or skip the wait while they replay another luge run or over-analyze the lift from some 3rd rate Chinese pairs skaters while they wait for scores to come up. I do however wish that the tape delay could start a little earlier. I was at my parents house for Sunday dinner and my mom couldn’t stay up late enough to see all of the pairs skate and that situation will probably occur again when the men and women skate and don’t finish until close to midnight even though the actual live event easily before her bedtime. I feel for her, but I stay up late all the time.
I'm the first person to admit that I'm wrong about a lot of things, but I'm going to be the last person to admit I'm wrong about what we're currently talking about.
Bolts from the Blue - General Manager: It is what it isn't
Ick
Wireless keyboard is being a jerk. Hopefully my meaning wasn’t lost in the missing letters and words. One of these days I’ll listen to Richard and start previewing my comments because I click post.
I'm the first person to admit that I'm wrong about a lot of things, but I'm going to be the last person to admit I'm wrong about what we're currently talking about.
Bolts from the Blue - General Manager: It is what it isn't
What about using Paragraphs?
So it’s easier to read?
by jbox on Feb 15, 2010 4:46 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
My train of thought
Is not often conducive to paragraphs, but I’ll keep it in mind.
I'm the first person to admit that I'm wrong about a lot of things, but I'm going to be the last person to admit I'm wrong about what we're currently talking about.
Bolts from the Blue - General Manager: It is what it isn't
I loved this
Thank you for waving at me.
by Winfield's Ghost on Feb 16, 2010 12:49 PM EST up reply actions
My issue...
…isn’t so much with the tape delay, but the overall lack of coverage. The NBC proclaimed “Signature Event” of the Winter Games is the Men’s Downhill. So what do we see? The podium finishers, the Americans, and a guy who crashed. That’s classic NBC. Ok, in that case, they did throw in one other skier, but he was skiing with a broken thumb and is leading the World standings right now, so maybe they felt obligated. Come on, that’s not covering an event. That’s framing Bode Miller. Because he’s American.
At least it left time for discussions of polar bears and Dreamworks promos.
That doesn't seem that bad to me
Individual sports aren’t nearly as watchable when you have a second rate athlete as the only thing on your television unless that athlete is a plucky American who your audience can root on his valiant effort. I can’t fault NBC for not showing us the 4th best Norwegian or the 3rd best Austrian as they attempt to do a personal best that won’t get them within shouting distance of a podium finish.
I do wish that they could have done something to make such a close finish more dramatic. I liked the replays where they had a Bode Miller shadow on the gold medalist. Seeing the “-0.12” in green and knowing the guys is winning is so 1990s. A graphic that let you see what the guy has to beat and how he’s taking different lines would help. When they had all that money to burn on Michael Phelps’ races they came up with a graphic to show World Records. That was pretty neat.
I'm the first person to admit that I'm wrong about a lot of things, but I'm going to be the last person to admit I'm wrong about what we're currently talking about.
Bolts from the Blue - General Manager: It is what it isn't

by 
















